Cracking up here! First, a nice, well-fitting suit does wonders, no matter what body is inside it (but I gave bonus points if someone looked like they lead a somewhat active lifestyle) and I paid far more attention to a person's smile than their height or physique. (This assumes they have a smile, knows how to smile, and have teeth that are well-cared for.)
Yes the online world plays to superficial attractors—at least at first. But only people who are lacking substance (IMO) stop there; fully hatched eggs want substance and not just style. And intelligence, kindness, compatible sense of humor, emotional availability, fiscal responsibility and empathy go so much further than a tall, yoked, billionaire (or even hundred thousandaire) with perfect hair and piercing blue eyes.
Also I might be jaded but I did date that unicorn show pony guy and was turned off by his unearned entitlement and philandering ways.